Dolores Park

McDonald's Solicited by City Hall for Dolores Park

Wouldn't this have looked awesome in the middle of Tallboy Terrace?

A slew of information obtained through the Sunshine Ordinance revealed that the SF Department of Recreation and Parks both neglected local businesses and put little thought into the commercialization of city parks.

As you may recall earlier this fall, many area local businesses, neighborhood “activists”, and Dolores Park neighbors were upset over “chain” businesses moving into Dolores.  The controversy stemmed from what they claimed was a lack of outreach done by Rec. & Parks on the program and quickly ballooned into a debate about what our parks should be used for.  Eventually groups circulated a petition claiming McDonald's would be next to move into Dolores (which I initially dismissed as hyperbole), threats were made against businesses planning on opening in park, and one of the two businesses canceled their plans to open.

Following the controversy, Rec. and Park director Phil Ginsburg wrote about the merits of food carts operating in SF Parks in the Chronicle, citing the popularity of “Creme Brulée Man, Sexy Soup Lady, Adobo Hobo, Soul Cocina and Mobile Pho” as well as the thriving scene in NYC's Central Park, where people can purchase “inexpensive and popular fare ranging from soup and sandwiches to Turkish tacos.”

In a city as diverse and dense as San Francisco, the Recreation and Park Department is devoted to maintaining and improving what open space we have. Bringing a carefully chosen cadre of food carts into our parks is a natural extension of that. Food provides a reason for gathering. Gatherings are where people interact and community is formed. Parks provide a natural space to gather. Uniting food and parks creates an active, dynamic space for San Franciscans to enjoy.

While his words would lead you to believe the Department was truly interested in assisting aspiring businesses, the preponderance of companies invited to bid were non-local businesses.  Among the notified companies were Auntie Annes Pretzels, Ben & Jerry’s, Burger King, Double Rainbow, Fuddruckers, Ghirardelli, Haagen Dazs, Jamba Juice, Nestle Café, Orange Julius, Peet's Coffee & Tea, Pizza Hut, Subway, TCBY, The Cheescake Factory, Walt Disney, Wendy’s, and World Wrapps.

Local businesses were almost completely ignored.  In fact, of the 910 companies contacted, only a few dozen local San Francisco companies were listed, including Boulevard (Downtown), Buena Vista Cafe (Marina), Burger Joint (Mission), Cable Car Coffee Company (Powell), Castro Cheesery (Castro), City Hall Cafe (Civic Center), Deli-Up Cafe (Mission), Graffeo Coffee (North Beach), Imperial Tea Court (multiple locations), It's-It Ice Cream, La Cocina (Mission), Zuni Cafe (Civic Center).  Even more troubling, no local food carts already operating in or around Dolores Park were told about the opportunity.

Program Lacked Proper Planning

Ginsburg's op-ed suggested that the Department had debated the merits of commercializing open spaces.  However, the requests for program plans revealed no such thought was put into the decision to privatize parks.  The request directly made to Recreation and Parks:

A copy of the business plan, strategic plan, work plan or any internal strategy documents surrounding this initiative/program. Documents that answer: How it was conceived? What are the pros/cons? What are the risks and mitigation of those risks? What were the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats of this idea? What are the financial projects? What are the liability issues? What is the environmental impact? What kind of outreach is necessary? What are the legal implications? Etc. 

The Department was unable to provide any documents for this request, which implies no strategy was put into the program and was initiated on a whim.

Future Commercialization

Under the program that is commercializing Dolores Park, many other neighborhood parks are going to be litered with food trucks.  Duboce Park is going to have a juice truck (company unknown), Marina Green will have Twirl and Dip Soft Serve and Annakoot Indian Food, the Band Shell in Golden Gate Park will have Blue Bottle Coffee, Little Guys Sliders, Sam’s Chowder-Mobile, and Waffle-Mania, and Civic Center will have Leba (a falafel truck) and Blue Bottle Coffee.

Nick Kinsey, the Assistant Director of Property and Concession Management for the Department of Recreation and Parks, also says that the Department is still accepting proposals for Dolores Park, but “I am not sure that we would consider anything additional at Dolores at this point.”

More Info

Initial Request for Proposals Letter [PDF]

List of Businesses Contacted [HTML]

My Day As Zombie Cold Beer! Cold Water!

My favorite day in Dolores Park, ever. Went down dressed as Zombie Cold Beer! Cold Water!. For those of you not from San Francisco, “Cold Beer! Cold Water!” is a man who walks around Dolores Park with a cooler bag selling, well, yeah…. cans of PBR (sometimes Simple Times) and water. Here are some photos of him. And while he’s not wearing this outfit in any of those shots, I promise this is pretty damn close to what he wore most days this summer.

I can do a pretty good impression of his call, and he kind of sounds like a zombie anyway, so I went with it. I had my zombie walk on, and set out hollering… over and over and over… “Cold beer! Cold Water!” Some people had no idea what was going on, but most people recognized who I was supposed to be. And THREE different people mistook me for the man himself, all saying something like, “Oh, my god! He dressed up for Halloween!” One man was convinced I stole CBCW’s shirt. Ganja Treats took my photo! I sold twelve beers and four waters (though I gave away like half of them). But where was the OG CBCW?

I got up to leave after a couple hours, carrying my cooler, continuing the zombie walk and yelling his call, when suddenly, I heard him. He was only fifty feet or so away from me. “Cold Beer!” he yelled. “Cold Water!” I responded. People were cracking up, and one woman came running after me demanding I go after him and take a photo. I was on my way out though and having never talked to dude in my life didn’t know if he’d really appreciate my costume and I chickened out. Still, I had a blast. 

Photos by Erin Steach.

That Building in the Middle of Dolores Park Used to be a Bandstand

The Bay Citizen just put together an interesting slideshow of Dolores Park throughout the years and posted up this nugget of Dolores history:

Jurors in the trial of Ramon Rodriguez, who admitted to beating 16-year-old Hilda Rosa Pagan by the park bandstand in the spring of 1952. Pagan's body was found in a hole behind the shrubbery to the right.

I had heard rumors from neighbors and park history buffs that the building in the middle of the park had been a one-level facilities building for years and that there was a second building for public restrooms, but I could never dig up a photo proving it (allegedly there is a photo of the Mayor in the 1950s addressing a large crowd in the park from the platform, but that photo seems to be lost too).  Well, this photo seems to back up both claims: the now-facilities building doesn't have a roof and on the corner of 19th and Dolores, a second building is clearly visible.

The story goes that between sometime in the '50s, a roof was put on the building and the city started selling concessions out of the space, only to shut down the space in the 1970s because of asbestos.  I suspect we won't be seeing the city try that again

In other news, it looks like the northeast corner of the park has been popular for decades.

(all photos from the San Francisco Historical Photograph Collection.  Via the Bay Citizen)

Get Yer T-shirts!

I hate this band The National. So while the flannel set were droning to their supremely unexciting set at Treasure Island Music Festival, I decided to keep my negativity to myself by browsing the vendors. That's where I met Mary Weather, aka Judy Elkan, a local screen printer who lets you buy your favorite free Mission landmarks in clothing form. She takes photos, sometimes collages them together as she did for this Dolores Park number, and applies them to [vertically integrated apparel brand] t-shirts and tank tops. 

Now you can be surrounded by the Sutro Trident of Hope, mafia-organized ice cream vendors, and piles of bicycles regardless of where you spend your Saturdays.  

Judy says the cops told her to get permit last year, but when she found out that only allowed her to sell at the Ferry Building, she defiantly raised a fist and set up her blanket/storefront at Dolores Park. Apparently the po po haven't given her any guff this year.

Sucks for Blue Bottle because the park is apparently a very lucrative spot. “My best day I made $400 in 3 hours” says Elkan.

Where do we draw the line on commercializing public spaces? Is Mary Weather eroding the fabric of the neighborhood by selling water-based fabric ink hand prints? Is this the first step on the road towards Mission souvenir shops and mass produced “I ♥ Dolores Park” mugs?

Or is this Count Chocula shirt cool enough to make you forget your morals?

Chicken John's Threats of Violence Stops Blue Bottle From Moving Into Dolores

I know half the blogs in San Francisco have already covered this, but I feel it would be inappropriate to not say something about Chicken John's role in all of this.  The Bay Citizen recently broke the news that Blue Bottle is out, with Blue Bottle owner Jason Freeman saying, “I don't need this controversy.”  While this should be something to celebrate—afterall, we get to keep out parks limited green space out of the hands of private entities—it's actually quite depressing:

And now, after blog comments about spitting and vague word of tire-slashing, Blue Bottle owner James Freeman said that he has decided not to drive his trailer into the park at all.

What James is referring to is comments left by none other than Chicken John, spokesfowl for the ZOMG SPOT “CORPORATE” AMERICA IN SF crowd.  As Chicken commented in a recent 7x7 post (edited for brevity):

Do we need to be protected? Do we need legislation that would prevent RPD from steamrolling a community park into selling off spots to stores?

I'm sure that this would make excellent dialog. You can guess how I would think. But as for BB, it seems as if they wish to be the company that 'breaks' Dolores Park. Which is going to be messy. And uncomfortable. Very uncomfortable. People are spitting mad. If it is true that they didn't see this comming, which I find impossible, then if I were them I'd run. There are going to be a thousand people there spitting on them on their opening day. Fucking riot cops. [emphasis added]

While Chicken didn't come right out and say he would be spitting on Blue Bottle's workers, he sure did imply that he and his army of Laughing Squid pendejos would be out there assaulting them.  I'm not saying Chicken was on the wrong side of the debate, hell, I was on his side, but threatening people and property is not how normal adults get their way.  That's how racists kept “niggers” out of their schools and neighborhood for generations.  That's how fellow demagogues scared people away for polls for years (and still do in many nations).  More recently, this is the type of behavior exhibited by Tea Party racists.  Chicken: just because you're fighting “the good fight” doesn't mean you get a free pass.

This wasn't the way to win.

What Not to Wear to Dolores Park

Here In San Francisco, a fantastic blog about being lesbian and making dog food and other such tomfoolery, spotted this unfortunate scene during the last crushing heatwave.  Considering tomorrow is going to be on the warmer side, I'd like to present this national tragedy as a kind reminder of what not to wear on your Tecate and Rhea's lunchbreak.

In other news, Here In SF recently got invited to a lunch with group of rowdy retired Irish and Italian boxers and baseball players in the Excelsior.  Needless to say, it sounds like a fantastic place to squander a Friday afternoon while shooting the shit with people who spend the better part of their life getting punch in the head.

Blue Bottle, La Cocina, and the Commercialization of Dolores Park

The debate surrounding the commercialization of Dolores Park sure has been heating up lately.  Earlier this week, Stephen Elliot, the man largely responsible for preventing American Apparel from opening up shop on Valencia Street in 2009, took up the cause and launched “Stop the Trailer.”  Stephen easily has the capability to see some success on this issue given his network of businesses and track-record of victory.  He even has devoted himself to undermine Blue Bottle's business by standing in front of their trailer and offering free coffee to all their patrons.

The general campaign against these trailers makes many good points: Dolores Park is already used to its max, the trailers, generators and accompanying lines will be a visual and audible blight and, most importantly, parks are meant to be for leisure, sport and unfettered drinking.

However, Stephen and other neighbor's campaign is being subverted by Chicken John.  He defends his use of the “McDonald's is coming!“ hyperbole in his straw-man petition because it was successful, “time was short and we needed knee-jerk reactions. Which we got.”  He spends his time trying to paint local business Blue Bottle as a corporate monster, but completely ignores that La Cocina will be operating a similar truck, all while parading around Ritual Roaster's trailer on federal land.  Worst of all, Chicken John is a man with previously no visibility on park matters.  Of the half dozen or so community meetings I've been to over the past year, he never once showed his face or rallied his crew of Laughing Squid fanboys.  This guy doesn't care about “Dolores Park's soul;” he is, yet again, merely using this controversy as a tool for self-promotion.

Time is poorly spent defining what types of businesses should be allowed to vend on public land.  More importantly, it's hard to fault Blue Bottle or La Cocina for taking this offer—Rec. & Park truly offered an incredible deal.  As anyone who has ever tried to open a business in San Francisco can tell you, the costs and red tape are outstanding.  One small Valencia St. retail outlet (no food or drink) that I know of spent $60,000 just to open the door and dealt with countless setbacks (ADA compliance, fire etc).  Serving food and drink makes it even more costly.  Yet Blue Bottle has only sunk $25,000 into their venture and La Cocina has reportedly spent $30,000.  To be granted a retail space with access 1.2 million patrons a year for such a staggeringly low start-up cost and, worst, only $1,000/month in rent is what is so disgusting.  As Blue Bottle's James Freeman told 7x7 Magazine, “It was less expensive than building out a cafe.”

And this is the problem with the deal.  Rather than fill up one of the dozen storefronts on Valencia or Mission with a business, we have incentivized businesses to plant 12-foot trucks in the middle of a park that is already pressed for space.  Even if Blue Bottle or La Cocina had to get a Dolores location, the storefront on the corner of 18th and Dolores next to Bi-Rite Cremery is up for rent.  Rec & Park should have recognized that if they were going to whore out one of our national treasures, they should have at least demanded more money per month than what I pay in rent.

Given all this, I recognize booting the trucks out of Dolores Park is an unwinnable war.  The contracts are in place, the permits have been drawn up and the trucks have been built.  Short of Chicken John taking a liter of gas and a match to the trucks, they'll be in The Park later this fall.  But kicking them out is not a war worth pursuing: it would be unfair to for these two groups, who are largely innocent in the whole ordeal, to eat the cost of the city's blunder.  Instead, Rec & Park should realize this was a grave mistake and when the permits are up in two years, not renew them and have Rec & Park head Phil Ginsburg assure us that this will never happen again.

A Nice Night to Walk Your LED Puppy

Not sure what this lone guy was trying to accomplish, but I watched him walk his leashed 2-dimensional puppy from 18th up to the top of the park, loop back down the hill, sit down to have a cigarette atop of Tallboy Terrace and then take off.  Then I quickly realized I just spent the last 5 minutes watching some burner walk his art project around a park…

Pages