Stabbing Outside of Dolores Park/Bi-Rite Market Leaves Pools of Blood on 18th and Oakwood

An anonymous tipster just sent this in:

I don't know what just happened on Oakwood (frankly, it looks pretty bad), but some bystanders allegedly claimed it was a stabbing that “had to do with drinking at Dolores Park all day.”  Just FYI.

No idea if it was related to the fight I witnessed earlier.  I'll update if I hear more.

Update: Ryan just emailed this in:

Just came home to find 19th between Guerrero and Dolores completely shut down, as well as most of that segment of 18th. Ambulances, fire trucks and cop cars lined the street in front of Bi-Rite, with some kid on a stretcher with an oxygen mask. I talked to some girl who, choking back sobs, managed to tell me that someone got stabbed. I tried to console her but she was pretty traumatized. I walked up to some cops and was berated by one of them, but the other said they were dealing with a stabbing, and to go inside.  I live right across the street and it looks like it occurred on Oakwood, connecting 18th and 19th, right next to the Bi-Rite market. Heavy.

Update II, from Jekka:

Update III with some additional thoughts:

There was undeniably some evil energy in the park today; quite unlike anything I've ever felt in the park before.  It was so bad that for the first time ever, I actually got up and left The Park because of the atmosphere.  And as Daniel tweeted, I clearly was not alone.  People at the vista corner of the park even were joking, “when the messengers from One Post bail and come up here, you know shit's fucked.”

I'm not saying this because I'm scared or freaked out or packing up my bags to move to Walnut Creek.  No, stabbings happen all the time in the Mission—it's terrible and inexcusable, but we all moved here knowing that. I say this because of what our tipster said in the first email. [It] had to do with drinking at Dolores Park all day.

We're assuredly going to hear in the coming weeks from the likes of C.W. Nevius, gray-haired neighbors, and “concerned parents and neighbors” about how it's time to cut back on the liberty we all enjoy and cherish.  “Shit has being going too far for too long.”  “A stabbing? What next? A SHOOTING?”

There'll be community meetings in which people berate Sup. Scott Wiener and the entire Parks & Rec staff.  There'll be demands for SFPD to crack down on public drinking.  I've sat in Dolores Park meetings exactly like this countless times—this aftermath is a given.

But what these people always miss—and this is important—is this horrible fight would have gone down no matter where these kids were drinking.  It could have been in an alley, or Precita Park, or under a bridge off of Cesar Chavez.  The truffles and the open containers on Hipster Hill were not the problem; no, an estimated 12 million people responsibly enjoy these liberties every day.  And I've logged more hours with my ass planted on Dolores Park's grass than anyone I know and I've never once before been made to feel the park wasn't safe.  The problem was these kids, specifically and individually.

So, please, let's not lose our collective shit over a couple of swine and ruin a beautiful thing.

Update IV: Here's the video I took of people fighting in the park earlier (in this video, they're chasing a dude out of the park).  If I had to make a guess, these are the people involved, as they were fighting shortly before the stabbing (I took the video 9 minutes before it went down), breaking bottles, brandishing knifes in the park, and generally acting like shitheads:

Update V: Mission Local reports two people were stabbed:

Officers responded to a call of multiple stabbing victims at approximately 6:30 p.m. As of 10:45 p.m., officers were leaving the scene. […]

Officer Albie Esparza said that five people were involved in a verbal altercation that escalated into a physical fight that injured two people. […]

Esparza said that the suspects, who are described as being in their 20s, fled the scene. The only description provided by police was that one suspect was short and the other stocky. [link]

Comments (41)

wait, kevin, what energy? were kids just fighting and shit? your video doesn’t really show what the title would suggest.

and yeah, i’m sure we’re about to see quite the shitstorm, huh.

The kids were fighting constantly, running around yelling, playing with knifes, breaking bottles on the grass. It was definitely a good day turned really, really bad.

I try to find the humor in things, and I wrote that post before I ever heard about the stabbing, which is why it is so light.

Yeah, no you’re good. It just fucking blows.

“Evil energy”? What does that mean? Can you be more specific about what you saw/felt? I’ve just never experienced this in the park (maybe I’m just oblivious) and am curious.

I’ll try and write more about this later. As of right now I’m tried and wanna watch One Tree Hill reruns.

It just didn’t feel like the regular “day in day out” scene at the Park. The group was being overly loud, breaking bottles, chasing people and being agro for no reason; apparently right before we got there there was another full on fight they were involved in as well. The time that we spent sitting there was uncomfortable (for me at least), and there was an ominous feel to it, like something was about to go down that we didn’t want to stick around for. At least that’s how I felt. It’s not something I’ve ever felt in the Park before, and I hope never to again.

This is still hearsay from other bystanders, but current story is that two dudes jumped someone known to them and then ditched a bag full of beer under a car whilst fleeing. Actual stabbing occurred at 19th and the guy inexplicably walked along Oakwood to 18th, where I saw him sitting and being questioned by cops who were trying to keep him conscious. Cops were all great, BTW.

Also, possibly related (?), an older woman had a heart attack on either 19th or Oakwood just after the stabbing and there were extra ambulances for her.

I’m not about to let this affect my enjoyment of the park or neighborhood. I agree with the “additional thoughts” that this could have happened anywhere.

And I’m vaguely amused by the crime scene tape by Bi-Rite. Fair amount of blood too. Oakwood is still blocked off, as of this posting.

It is a tasteless comment in reference to the juxtaposition of violent crime and fabulous produce.

These morons have been sitting in the middle of the hill for days. Haight Street gutter Punks!

Thanks for the info, just got turned on to this site.

I live across from the park and walked outside my house to hit bi-rite for dinner and came across this whole scene. The cops on the scene were complete dicks. They saw me walk out of my house, (which I pay insane property taxes on, which in turns pays their salary in some indirect way I’m assuming – oldest one in the book but seems particularly poignant here), and then acted all indignant when I had the audacity to ask in a polite tone why my street was closed down with police tape everywhere. I know, this is a bit off topic but the quote about being berated by the cop got to me.

I moved to this neighborhood 10 years ago and I feel like the cops have become more and more aggressive with each passing day, and have used every excuse to exercise more and more power in the name of safety. One of them actually punched my car as I was driving last week. Seriously, that actually happened. I have been physically intimidated by them twice now since I moved here (counting car-punch 2012). I am a gainfully employed, law-abiding citizen who minds my own business, pays my taxes, and works hard to be able to live here. Yet every day the people I fear most are the cops in my own neighborhood. Not getting stabbed at the park, not getting shot on 20th, the cops.

True, if someone was breaking into my house, the first thing I would do was call the cops. But that doesn’t change any of what I just said. Just because someone relies on you for help doesn’t mean you have the right to treat them like dogs.

Anyways, what happened tonight is sad but typical. In just the past year that girl got stabbed 11 times at the dog drinking fountain, the guy got stabbed/robbed up at the top, and the other guy got shot 4 times at 20th. Urban parks will be urban parks. All the gentrification in the world won’t help that I’m afraid.

Insert Ben Franklin liberty quote here; but seriously, keep the park free. These idiots will kill each other no matter where you put them.

When I was at the park during lunch, there was a crowd(probably the same or related crowd) of gutter punks fighting, while some girl in the group who kept telling everyone “it’s o.k. they are friends and they just need to do this”. They would fight and then hug it out. It was fucking strange. Of course someone in the group ended up getting punched in the mouth and then things got even more weird. We left not long after a guy who may or may not have been from another come over a kick the dudes on the ground fighting.

Thanks for the details

Where’s Stop Snitchin’?

I stabbed him on Oakwood…

Sounds like Dolores Park when I lived across the street from it in 1993. Except instead of two stabbed out of thousands, it would have been two stabbed out of the 12 people who were lingering in the park.

I shoulda done something when I was there during the day. I’ll take an ass beating trying to “police” the park if some of you all want to help. Just let me know. cheers

Sounds like a case of “someone should have called the cops sooner.”

As much as it sucks to be the guy who calls the cops to the park, as we’ve seen here the consequences of NOT being “that guy” can be worse.

I can’t help but be a little peeved reading this. The park has been a gang war zone for years. Dealers used to get cops to escort them out of the neighborhood because they were scared of getting shot. All this skinny jean expensive ice cream and beer shit started less than 5 years ago. Yeah, there’s probably going to be some fights. Don’t act surprised. You’re new.

You’re peeved that gangs and drug dealers don’t run the park anymore?

It’s been more than five years. I remember drankin’ sparks in the park , like, at least 7 years ago. But what do I know, I’ve only lived here for 15 years.

I don’t think anyone is surprised by fights - they’re surprised by white kids stabbing each other.

The park hasn’t been a “gang war zone” since the mid 90s, but if by “gang war zone” you meant, “guys selling $20 bags by the basketball courts”, ok, that went on until around 2002….

We’re assuredly going to hear in the coming weeks from the likes of C.W. Nevius, gray-haired neighbors, and “concerned parents and neighbors” about how it’s time to cut back on the liberty we all enjoy and cherish. “Shit has being going too far for too long.”

I dislike Nevius, but I am graying hair neighbor and concerned parent.

The fun at Dolores Park is good for all of us, including those of us too old to fit. Answer is Community Policing. Things like cops on ten speed bikes, rather than any zero tolerance policy. Keep the fun, but get rid of the agro idiots.

Also, if you enjoy your drinking all day in the park, and you yourself acknowledge that the energy was so bad that you fled (even if it was just up the hill), then do us all a favor and call the cops to clean the “bad energy” out of the park before shit like this happens. Breaking glass all over the grass? And you just walked away?

People are properly skeptical that the police will handle the issue without going overboard and cracking down on healthy fun It often makes sense to walk away.

Why do you think it is okay to sit there and watch people breaking glass, brandishing knives and fighting? If no one has the guts to say anything then these incidents will never stop. Plus, it is not all fun and free over there on the Hill…go walk over there at 6 in the morning and see the piles of trash that are left daily. If you want it to stay free and happy you best take care of it and speak up next time!

If you thought there was a chance you would be stabbed then in no uncertain terms you should have called the police. You could have walked away from the area and done that so that none of the perpetrators would have known who called. You are as much to blame as them for trashing our park and putting the “freedom” at risk.

Seriously, call the cops – I saw a very similar situation in the past and called the cops. They drove up, gave the crowd the evil eye (from the car) until one of the guys came over to the car to chat with them… and the cops left and the group settled down. Honestly, the cops don’t have time to make a huge deal out of something that is about to happen but hasn’t happened yet, but they can prevent it from happening by showing up. If you don’t take responsibility for your community, events like this will lead to a much more drastic damper on park activity – like zero tolerance for open containers. So step up and do your part to keep the park sane – particularly because the park is for everyone – including people with kids and older people.


and that was an amen to “I type”

Wow, first sensible thing I’ve heard all day. Thanks, type.

The park has already been “gentrified” by hipsters – they’re usually the front-line gentrifiers.

Yes, I am a parent of a person living where the stabbings occurred. This person was raised in “liberal” areas, by “liberal ” parents, attended private “liberal” schools, and was educated in non-violence.

After this person sent me a link to the stabbing info. I immediately “reverted” to my (previously unknown) “inner Republican”. My kid needed to move, immediately ( Yes, Walnut Creek sounds appropriate, a gated community), increase police presence in the area, everyone needs to constantly call the police.

I see that other bloggers are already expecting such parental responses, so I obliged.

I popped by a week ago for lunch during the insanely nice weather. Plenty of people selling all sorts of things even before the park really filled up, and one shoeless crazy looking fella was telling another vendor to stay off his turf, literally drawing some sort of line in the dirt. Things were fairly civilized, but the guy came back and they were just starting to have another “conversation” as we left.

Totally different situation, but I felt some bad energy there related to the commerce going on. Sure, nothing like 15 years ago (or so I’m told), but I had to wonder long it would be until some enterprising SF State dealer got his head bashed in by a more lifelong criminal element.

Little school children pampered to death who claim to know how everything turns out, desperate to keep fucking/smoking/drinking before mom and dad get home. Pathetic waste of a generation.

Don’t worry. Things will improve when the playground opens up and you have the likes of me and my kids in the park again. I have no problem calling the cops on knife-wielders. And I also have no problem with drinking beer and smoking pot in the park.

Any followup to this?

Post New Comment